-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/product/pdf/methods-guide-inclusion-nonrandomized-studies.pdf
September 01, 2022 - Finally, we outline an approach to
incorporating NRSIs within an SR and key considerations for reporting … The analysis, synthesis, and reporting of NRSIs also require special attention. … However, NRSIs may be susceptible to publication and other reporting biases because NRSIs are
usually … In general, NRSIs and, if any, RCTs, should be reported together when reporting findings for
a given … Reporting
the SR
When NRSIs are included:
17.
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/wysiwyg/pdf/methods-guide-inclusion-nonrandomized-studies.pdf
September 01, 2022 - Finally, we outline an approach to
incorporating NRSIs within an SR and key considerations for reporting … The analysis, synthesis, and reporting of NRSIs also require special attention. … However, NRSIs may be susceptible to publication and other reporting biases because NRSIs are
usually … In general, NRSIs and, if any, RCTs, should be reported together when reporting findings for
a given … Reporting
the SR
When NRSIs are included:
17.
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/products/antipsychotics-children-update/research-protocol
April 01, 2020 - Moreover, to enhance reporting on subgroups the previous KQ on subgroups has been integrated into the … We will also not assess selective outcome reporting at the study level, since this will be considered … outcome reporting bias, and selective analysis reporting bias; this will only be assessed for evidence … for individual studies and reporting patterns across studies. … To assist with publication/reporting bias assessments, we will seek abstracts (publication bias only)
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/renal-artery-stenosis_executive-2007.pdf
January 01, 2007 - The quality of the evaluated studies was
limited because of inadequate reporting and/or
collection of … with and without stent); limited
applicability due to restrictive patient eligibility or
inadequate reporting
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/products/behavioral-interventions-migraine-prevention/protocol
April 01, 2024 - Although we will assess selective outcome reporting, we will not incorporate it in the overall risk of … bias rating because the EPC SOE system places it in the Reporting Bias domain (along with publication … The primary domains assessed include risk of bias, directness, consistency, precision, and reporting … Reporting bias . … magnitude of effects identified in included studies, possible selective outcome reporting, and noting
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/products/interventional-treatments-pain/protocol
February 01, 2021 - ; large amounts of missing information; discrepancies in reporting; or serious problems with intervention … The aggregate risk of bias across individual studies reporting an outcome is considered. … Reporting bias (suspected or undetected)
Publication bias, selective outcome reporting, and selective … analysis reporting are types of reporting bias. … Reporting bias is difficult to assess as systematic identification of unpublished evidence is challenging
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/products/uterine-fibroids/research-protocol
May 01, 2019 - Studies reporting only outcomes related to healthcare delivery (e.g., costs, access) will not be included … Studies reporting only intermediate outcomes will not be included. … If we are unable to resolve a discrepancy in the reporting of data from a publication we may contact … We will assess reporting bias of randomized controlled trials by examining outcomes of trials as reported … Preferred reporting items for systematic review and meta-analysis protocols (PRISMA-P) 2015: elaboration
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/pdf/safety-vaccines-protocol.pdf
January 30, 2020 - Multiple publications reporting on the same participant groups will be counted
as single studies and … Throughout the data
abstraction process, publications reporting on the same participant group will be … criteria assessing two main domains:108, 109
• Data collection of adverse events
• Reporting of … bias, selective
outcome reporting, or selective reporting of the analysis) and undetected bias (no … We do not expect substantial reporting bias given that the decision to publish
will have likely been
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/products/infertility/research-protocol
October 01, 2019 - The majority of RCTs were not designed to detect differences in pregnancy and live birth rates; reporting … ; no reporting errors; a low dropout rate; and clear reporting of dropouts. … in reporting. … bias, which includes publication bias, outcome reporting, and analysis reporting bias, as described … Improving the reporting of clinical trials of infertility treatments (IMPRINT): modifying the CONSORT
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/products/cerebral-palsy-feeding/research-protocol
December 01, 2019 - Risk of selection, reporting, and other bias are assessed in the Quality Assessment Form Part I. … Bias
Selective reporting
State how the possibility of selective outcome reporting was examined … Reviewer Comments:
Reporting bias due to selective outcome reporting. … Judgment: Selective reporting
High
Low
Unclear
Other bias
Other sources of bias … Risk of selection, reporting, and other bias are assessed in the Quality Assessment Form Part I.
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/products/safety-vaccines/protocol
January 01, 2021 - Multiple publications reporting on the same participant groups will be counted as single studies and … Throughout the data abstraction process, publications reporting on the same participant group will be … criteria assessing two main domains: 108 , 109
Data collection of adverse events
Reporting of … bias, selective outcome reporting, or selective reporting of the analysis) and undetected bias (no bias … We do not expect substantial reporting bias given that the decision to publish will have likely been
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/pdf/renal-cancer_clinician.pdf
July 01, 2017 - on the ratings for the following domains: study limitations, directness, consistency, precision, and reporting … of a standardized biopsy protocol
�– Weak study designs (e.g., retrospective studies)
�– The lack of reporting … on the levels of surgeon/
pathologist/radiologist expertise
�– Poor reporting of clinical staging
�– … Inconsistent reporting of treatment outcomes
�� Currently, there is no composite model that reliably … In the single study reporting minor and major
Clavien complication rates, major rates were similar
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/pdf/lung-cancer-staging_research-protocol.pdf
December 08, 2014 - • For comparative tumor response (part of KQ2), this means reporting the
percentage of patients … • For comparative survival (part of KQ2), this means either reporting median
survival after each … • For patient factors or tumor characteristics (KQ3), this means reporting data
on whether such … Studies reporting multiple outcomes may be assigned one risk-of-bias category for some
outcomes but … Reporting bias.
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/antiplatelet-treatment_executive.pdf
September 01, 2013 - We also excluded studies reporting
exclusively on healthy individuals. … There was also substantial risk of selective
outcome reporting for outcomes other than MACE. … These results need to be interpreted with caution, given the
poor reporting of study methods and the … Randomized Trials Reporting Information on Treatment-
Effect Modification by CYP2C19 Genotype Status … We identified 13 publications (reporting on 12 study
populations) describing randomized controlled
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/products/renal-cancer/clinician
December 01, 2019 - on the ratings for the following domains: study limitations, directness, consistency, precision, and reporting … of a standardized biopsy protocol
Weak study designs (e.g., retrospective studies)
The lack of reporting … on the levels of surgeon/pathologist/radiologist expertise
Poor reporting of clinical staging
Inconsistent … reporting of treatment outcomes
Currently, there is no composite model that reliably predicts … In the single study reporting minor and major Clavien complication rates, major rates were similar but
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/products/acs-pci-adjunctive-devices/research-protocol
December 01, 2019 - comparison groups; appropriate measurement of outcomes; appropriate statistical and analytic methods and reporting … ; no reporting errors; less than 20 percent dropout; and clear reporting of dropouts. … They have serious errors in design, analysis, or reporting; large amounts of missing information; or … discrepancies in reporting.
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/epc-disclosure-policy-form.pdf
March 01, 2023 - threatens the validity of clear
and cogent findings and jeopardizes the public's trust in science and reporting … However, open response resulted in high variability with both over- and under-reporting at
times. … In 2009, the International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE) developed a COI
reporting form … However, open response resulted in high variability with both over- and under-reporting at times. … In 2009, the International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE) developed a COI reporting form
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/products/attention-deficit-hyperactivity-disorder/protocol
July 01, 2022 - Finally, no comparator is needed anymore for studies reporting on long-term effects, and these studies … Publications reporting on the same participants will be consolidated into one study record. … Reporting bias: Reporting bias assessment will include an evaluation of whether a pre-specified analysis … Reporting bias: Occurs when publication or reporting of findings is based on their direction or magnitude … Publication bias, selective outcome reporting, and selective analysis reporting are types of reporting
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/infantile-hemangioma_executive.pdf
January 01, 2016 - We considered 14 of
these as good quality for harms reporting, 3 as fair quality
for harms reporting … , and the remainder (n=127) as poor
quality for harms reporting. … We rated all case series as poor
quality for harms reporting. … Of the 219 children who received steroids in three
comparative studies reporting such data, 140 had … We considered all to be
poor quality for harms reporting and insufficient SOE for
association with
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/products/multiple-sclerosis/research-protocol
December 01, 2019 - The observational literature likely to be included rarely has protocols available to assess reporting … bias for this topic, likely including participant selection; attrition, detection, selective outcome reporting … develop items for both risk-of-bias instruments to assess selective outcome and selective analysis reporting … direction and size); and (4) precision (degree of certainty around an estimate). 16 A fifth domain, reporting … Selective Outcome Reporting as a Source of Bias in Reviews of Comparative Effectiveness.