-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/pdf/cad-women-diagnosis-future_research_1.pdf
February 01, 2013 - Summary from all studies with no known CAD:
• 41 studies (13 good quality, 22 fair, 6 poor) of exercise … ECG showed a summary sensitivity of
62% and specificity of 68%
• 22 studies (8 good quality, 13 … quality studies of women with no known CAD, studies of
women from mixed populations, and good quality … Predictors of diagnostic
accuracy in women Insufficient
11 studies (4 good quality, 5 fair, 2 poor … Safety concerns Insufficient
13 studies (9 good quality, 4 fair) reported data pertinent to safety
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/menopause_disposition-comments.pdf
March 05, 2015 - The rationale for excluding patients with breast
cancer, in my mind, is about as good as the rationale … The discussion section is generally good. … The attention to the
important problem of the widespread use of compounded hormones
and the lack of good … evidence about these products is very good. … For these 2 reasons, report was rated as
fair...otherwise, it would have been rated as good.
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/pdf/atrial-fibrillation_research-protocol.pdf
May 22, 2012 - assessment instruments detailed in AHRQ’s Methods Guide.51 Briefly, we will rate each
study as being of good … For all studies, the
overall study quality will be assessed as follows:
• Good (low risk of bias). … They did not meet all the criteria required for a rating of good quality because
they had some deficiencies … Thus, RCTs will be graded good, fair,
or poor, and observational studies will separately be graded good … assessment instruments
detailed in AHRQ’s Methods
Guide.51 Briefly, we will rate
each study as being of good
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/ptsd-comments.pdf
November 04, 2020 - This is a good suggestion and one we will
consider if there is future funding for these
efforts. … TEP 1 Results footnote of Fig 2, that's some impressive
transparency, good work
Noted. … We agree that this would be a good
next step, and in fact, have been
coordinating to support this work … And that
risk of bias assessment may not have good
reproducibility. ...and that some ROB was done … The search strategies are explicitly
stated and conform with good practice.
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/cer-208-bipolar-adults-disposition-comments.pdf
August 07, 2018 - 2018
3
Section
Reviewer,
Affiliation
Comment Response
Introduction Peer Reviewer
#5
Good … In our
experience, searches of very old
literature is often not a good use of
resources available … Results –
Acute Mania
Peer Reviewer
#6
The olanzapine studies provide a good example. … The present
review does a good job of noting funding sources of included
studies. … Trial and ERROR is
not good enough to treat people with these illnesses. FOR
SHAME!!!!
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/lung-cancer-nonsurgical-therapies_executive.pdf
June 01, 2013 - Patients with good performance status may benefit from
external-beam radiotherapy (EBRT), which comprises … potential
confounders
Comparative studies were rated according to one of three
quality categories:
Good … This allowed us to
differentiate the quality of single-arm studies as good, fair,
or poor. … For a study to be ranked good quality, all eight
Carey and Boden criteria mentioned above had to be … KQ1, as the former may
be relatively healthier than the latter, but they still are not as healthy as good
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/asthma-treatment_executive.pdf
May 01, 2011 - MV = minute volume; PEF = peak expiratory flow
4
Two independent reviewers assigned ratings of “good … testing to confirm reversible component)
• Retention (retention of 90% or more overall was
considered good … (so could not be assessed) if the rest of
the methods were judged to be “good.” … We abstracted data from all included studies with a quality
rating of “fair” or “good” into a standard … There were
no trials rated as “good” quality and a number of trials
could barely be considered “fair
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/selecting-evidence-quiz.ppt
May 29, 2025 - Although they may be a good source of information for planning future research and may provide some preliminary
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/manges.pdf
May 29, 2025 - So, we really have done a good job in the superfund program, which has
been doing it for 30 years now
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/selecting-evidence-quiz.ppt
May 29, 2025 - Although they may be a good source of information for planning future research and may provide some preliminary
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/antibiotics-respiratory-infection_disposition-comments.pdf
January 27, 2016 - Delayed antibiotic prescribing for respiratory
infections is not a good solution. … It would be good to include
these results in the manuscript. … Grading was good. … We have corrected the text
to reflect that Francis, 2009
is a good-quality study.
128. … There is likely a good
reason why this has not been studied
as an outcome.
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/cell-free-dna-disposition-comments.pdf
May 14, 2025 - The results from the K-DETEK cohort, with
100% sensitivity and 99.9% specificity,
seem entirely too good … Although these types are defined in methods
I think it would be good to help the reader
again in the … }
- 3.6.1: might be good to state more clearly
for the reader why the excess radiation level
cut-off … It would be
good to talk about CHIP in this report and
this may be a great place to do it. … will need to be overcome in
developing multicancer detection tests that
fulfill the criteria of a good
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/trauma-interventions-maltreatment-child_disposition-comments.pdf
April 15, 2013 - The authors could benefit from a good dose of Bayesian thinking:
With Bayesian analysis, assertions … Peer Reviewer
#3
Discussion/Conclusion The authors in their final section have good discussions of … partner with state or local agencies that have variably low staffing and
resources or standards for good … Future research section points the way to good research but may not make that
research possible given … Peer Reviewer
#8
Introduction I thought the introduction did a good job explaining the rationale,
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/pdf/labor-dystocia_research-protocol.pdf
July 28, 2016 - based on
recommendations in the AHRQ’s Methods Guide.20 Briefly, we will rate each study as
being of good … For all studies,
the overall study quality will be assessed as follows:
• Good (low risk of bias). … They did not meet all the criteria required for a rating of good quality because
they had some deficiencies … Thus, RCTs will be graded good,
fair, or poor, and observational studies will separately be graded good … A Good Birth: Finding the Positive and the Profound in your
Childbirth Experience.
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/mental-illness-adults-prisons_disposition-comments.pdf
August 21, 2013 - They did not conduct a meta-
analysis, but they did do a good job of justifying the lack of
available … Methods: The authors did a good job of detailing the
focus of this review, the method of obtaining relevant … General Comments: Report does a good job in defining
target populations, etc. … Phyllis Solomon, Gary Bond are 2 good
sources. … Dissertations are a good source of grey
literature studies and are often thoroughly reported.
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/medication-adherence-interventions_disposition-comments.pdf
September 11, 2012 - That
being noted, the authors do a very good job at explaining their rationale
and paths to conclusions … Peer Reviewer #5 Introduction Page 5: would be good here to have a table of all of the 16 components … Peer Reviewer #5 Introduction Page 10 - would have been good to include this list intervention types … section feels like something that a reader with general
interest could go over and come away with a good … has been missed
Thank you
Peer Reviewer #5 Discussion/
Conclusion
Future research section is good
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/fatty-acids-cardiovascular-disease_disposition-comments.pdf
August 12, 2016 - Since this question may be of interest to a reasonable proportion of the
readers, it would, be good … 11
Commentator &
Affiliation Section Comment Response
Peer Reviewer #2 General I believe that a good … A good job was done in
identifying these populations, which are both clinically meaningful and
important … Furthermore, exclusion of
small trials with lipid and BP outcomes are in my opinion not a good
decision … Very good, small trials are no
excluded, I have my doubts about that.
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/ischemic-stroke-treatment_executive.pdf
January 01, 2011 - analysis of the
IMS I and II trials, where reduced-dose IV followed by
IA thrombolysis was associated with good … They found
that when compared with a similar matched cohort, the
neurothrombectomy patients had good … suggesting that the neurothrombectomy
group was nearly 15 times more likely than the control
group to have good
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/liver-cancer-therapy_executive.pdf
May 01, 2013 - It has the
following thresholds for good, fair, and poor quality,22
which were applied to the RCTs … and nonrandomized
comparative studies:
• Good: Studies graded “good” meet all criteria;
comparable … A study was ranked as good quality if each of the
Carey and Boden23 criteria listed above was met, a … quality without confirmation by at least
1 other study of good or fair quality supports an SOE rating … RFA to PEI/PAI
Overall survival Moderate One good-quality RCT (n = 139) and 2 fair-quality RCTs (n =
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/technical-brief-34-health-worker-certification-summary.pdf
March 01, 2020 - May keep out candidate CHWs with extensive
experience in the community who are not
good test-takers.