-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/cer78_procalcitonin_disposition_20121210.pdf
October 05, 2012 - It
provides a very good overview of key elements of the
CER. … Breaking down the included studies across
five different patient populations was a good strategy. … Table 31 summarizing the scope of all five systematic
reviews was helpful and a good illustration. … Although antibiotic stewardship programs would
be a good comparator, there were no RCT’s comparing PCT … Given the option, I would
have preferred a rating of very good for this draft as
opposed to good or
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/ptsd-pharm-non-pharm-treatment-update-disposition-comments.pdf
August 28, 2024 - Like a traffic light, green is good
and red is bad (biased). … Peer Reviewer
#1
Discussion
and
Conclusion
Good discussion Thank you, no further
response necessary … conducted longer
term overviews of
changes over time,
though this type of
project would be a
good … 2024
16
Commentator &
Affiliation Section Comment Response
Peer Reviewer
#3
Results Very good
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/stroke-atrial-fibrillation_disposition-comments.pdf
August 23, 2013 - Thank you
Peer Reviewer
#4
General:
Quality of the
Report
Good Thank you
Peer Reviewer … General:
Quality of the
Report
Superior Thank you
TEP #2 General:
Quality of the
Report
Good … The key questions are good. … TEP #4 Methods Inclusion exclusion criteria are very good for
population studies. … Has less good predictive value
for CV events (and less good compared to a
multivariate analysis)
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/dental-jaw-rapid-response.pdf
May 01, 2025 - • There is insufficient evidence from one study each showing no impact of root canal
treatment (good … We rated one retrospective cohort study as good quality (low risk of bias) due to their
considerations … et al. as fair quality due to the lack of
blinding in outcome assessment,46 and Ristow et al.45 as good … • All 13 MRONJ-specific guidelines stress preventive dental measures, including good oral
hygiene … Recommendations pertaining to preventive
dental care included: good oral hygiene, fluoride toothpaste
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/rural-telehealth-disposition-comments.pdf
December 26, 2022 - The reader does not get a good description of the costs of the implementation for the studies,
the themes … The reader does not have a good feel for patient safety/unintended consequences during
the studies.
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/pneumonia-antibiotic-treatment_disposition-comments.pdf
November 24, 2014 - Peer Reviewer
#4
Introduction The Intro is generally good. … TEP Reviewer
#4
Introduction Good job clearly defining HAP, VAP, HCAP; the notion of
using PK/PD … TEP Reviewer
#5
Introduction Well written and of good size. Thank you for your comment. … The question
arises how good and reproducible is bias scale? … The investigators did a good job defining the
population(s) of interest as well as the questions.
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/labor-nitrous-oxide_executive.pdf
August 01, 2012 - Risk of Bias tool
and Newcastle-Ottawa Quality Assessment Scale results to
the AHRQ standard of “good … pain management (KQ2)
8 (2,825) High Consistent Direct Imprecise
Low; includes 2 RCTs; 1 study of
good … birth (KQ3)
6 (33,031) High Inconsistent Direct Imprecise
Insufficient; includes 2 RCTs; 1
study of good … tolerability (KQ4)
48 (27,530) High Consistent Direct Imprecise
Moderate; includes18 RCTS; 2
studies of good … Conclusions
The literature addressing nitrous oxide for the management
of labor pain has few studies of good
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/breast-cancer-imaging_disposition-comments.pdf
October 01, 2014 - Peer Reviewer
#4
General
Comments
Very good report overall. … Guiding
Questions
Good. We appreciate this comment. … There is a lot of focus on PET/CT in this section, and maybe for
good reason. … Peer Reviewer
#5
General
Comments
Good description of current studies on multiple tests. … Online: October 1, 2014
9
Commentator &
Affiliation Section Comment Response
Findings Good
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/pdf/schizophrenia-adult_research-protocol.pdf
September 23, 2016 - 8
• Study Designs
o Key Questions 1 and 2:
Best-evidence approach:
§ Recent, comprehensive, good … Studies will be rated as “good,” “fair,” or “poor,” or as specified by the particular
criteria. … Studies rated “good” quality will be considered to have the least risk of bias, and their
results will … Good-quality studies include clear descriptions of the
population, setting, interventions, and comparison … These studies may not meet all the criteria for a rating of good
quality, but no flaw is likely to cause
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/labor-nitrous-oxide_disposition-comments.pdf
August 23, 2012 - None pertinent to effectiveness were, it seems, were
judged be of good quality. … Good Thank you. … You should also
refer to the appendix, which is very good
Thank you. … These are good questions for future
research, which is sorely needed. … report given the small number of good quality papers on the
subject.
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/pressure-ulcer-treatment_disposition-comments.pdf
May 08, 2013 - Catherine
Ratliff
Methods good did not look at medical device
related? … James
Adamson
Methods Research methods appear very
good and thorough. … The tables do a good
job of presenting the relevant data
and provide a good overview of the
relevant … We
don’t have good evidence of
treatment for pressure ulcers. … Catherine
Ratliff
References good Thank you for your comment.
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/arcia-presentation.pdf
May 29, 2025 - the Other Men
were in
better health
because they only had
two bad
stars and three good … Is this a good example? Is this good image?"
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/pdf/TND_0352_09-22-2010.pdf
January 01, 2010 - A review addressing perinatal depression treatment will be a good companion to an in-process
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/renal-update_disposition-comments.pdf
August 16, 2016 - Good idea. We have created an
abbreviations page at the beginning of the
report. … This is a good point. … This is a good point. … This is a good point that we have added to
the Summary of findings, in the Discussion. … TEP Reviewer
#7
Discussion/
Conclusion
Discussion is good.
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/cer-193-disposition-comments-naloxone.pdf
November 27, 2017 - TEP Reviewer
#5
General
Comments
This is a good review of the literature and my
enthusiasm is … Ryan
Methods Good methodology when dealing with a
complicated mostly community based question
and … Tables with summaries of the studies are good.
Inclusion of appropriate studies good. … Good
presentation of bias level up front.
Thank you for the
comment. … TEP Reviewer
#4
Results Good detail Thank you for the
comment.
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/ankyloglossia_disposition-comments.pdf
May 04, 2015 - Peer reviewer #2 Introduction Key questions are good. … Peer reviewer #3
Discussion /
Conclusions
Good discussion Thank you for your comment. … Good overview of project.
Thank you for your comment. … These tools also have been shown to have good
inter-rater reliability. … TEP reviewer #8 Results Everything looks good. I appreciate the summary of my
thesis.
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/musculoskeletal-complaints-tests-children_disposition-comments.pdf
March 07, 2012 - There is no good evidence to support the reviewer’s
suggestion that titer matters – and the titer chosen … this paper,
reporting the prevalence of ANAs in the pediatric SLE
population seem really, really good … Peer Reviewer
#4
Introduction The introduction is good. … I think that
it was a good idea to have done the extra subanalyses for
the JIA categories when data … The explanation of the report's limitations, especially when
using case-control studies, was very good
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/coronary-artery-stenting_disposition-comments.pdf
February 26, 2013 - Quality of the Report: Good
This impressive review is an excellent summary of the impact
of FFR and … Peer Reviewer 6 General Comments Quality of the Report: Good
Nicely performed review of available evidence … Peer Reviewer 7 General Comments Quality of the Report: Good
In general, the authors should be commended … There is a good summary of different types of
intravascular diagnostic techniques currently in use either … Overall presentation looks good Thank you.
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/cer-243-prehospital-airway-management-disposition-comments.pdf
June 14, 2021 - Options are good. Every service is
different. … and
Conclusions
The key question on BVM suggests a benefit from a
two-rescuer team to maintain a good … Our findings
highlight the fact that good
training programs need to
teach a variety of skills
related … Public
Reviewer #6
General The critical deficiency of good evidence regarding
airway management options … The key question on BVM suggests a benefit from a
two-rescuer team to maintain a good seal.
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/hro-protocol.pdf
January 01, 2023 - safety coaches to coach their peers in the use of error
prevention techniques; routine sharing of good … Services Task Force Methods
Workgroup for assessing the quality of systematic reviews.12
8
• Good … We will rely primarily on the reviews of good
quality.