-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/dementia-nursing-home-characteristics_disposition-comments.pdf
October 23, 2012 - Peer Reviewer
#2
Discussion The discussion is thoughtful, despite major limitations in the data
available … TEP Reviewer
#4
Discussion It may be appropriate to include in discussion/conclusion
additional specifics … There is
some discussion of this issue in the "Research Gaps" section, but
more discussion of how to … Peer Reviewer
#5
Discussion I found the intro to the Discussion section readable and
informative. … Thank you
Peer Reviewer
#5
Discussion The discussion of Research Gaps beginning on page 55 is
thoughtful
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/pdf/linking-evidence-reviews-methods_0.pdf
October 01, 2018 - Reviews to Organizational Guideline Planning: A Pilot Test of an Interactive Web-Based Presentation and Discussion … to Organizational Guideline
Planning: A Pilot Test of an Interactive, Web-Based
Presentation and Discussion … to Organizational Guideline
Planning: A Pilot Test of an Interactive, Web-Based
Presentation and Discussion … These questions helped frame the cyberseminar agenda and discussion. … We also documented participant discussion and questions during the
cyberseminar itself.
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/delirium-disposition-comments.pdf
September 03, 2019 - TEP Peer
Reviewer #1
Discussion In the discussion, the Contrast to the SCM guidelines gets
nit picky … TEP Peer
Reviewer #1
Discussion/
Conclusion
The discussion needs one clarification “In the discussion … /
Conclusion
Discussion is well written. … See Major Comment above and
consider modifying Discussion to address that point. … sends a reader to the subpopulation
discussion.
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/atrial-fibrillation_disposition-comments.pdf
June 28, 2013 - TEP #1 ES (Discussion/
Conclusion)
2. … TEP #1 ES (Discussion/
Conclusion)
4. … TEP #4 ES (Discussion/
Conclusion)
Some of the Discussion also sounds a little self-congratulatory … TEP #6 Summary/
Discussion/
Conclusion
The discussion was appropriate and the conclusions are resonable … TEP #8 Summary/
Discussion/
Conclusion
The discussion of future research needs is very valuable for
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/ems-911-workforce-disposition-comments.pdf
November 01, 2022 - We have included
some of these points in our discussion
section. … NAEMT Discussion We agree that more research needs to be completed. Thank you for your comment. … For this reason, we
have included, where relevant, other
excluded studies in our discussion. … However, we have included
some of those excluded articles in the
discussion. … We also include vaccines and
vaccine mandates in our discussion and
conclusion sections.
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/bundled-payments-quality-effects_disposition-comments.pdf
August 24, 2012 - We added a brief discussion of this
issue to the summary and discussion chapter. … In the summary and discussion
chapter, we added a discussion that we did not
exclude any studies based … We added a brief discussion of this issue to the
summary and discussion chapter. … We added a brief discussion of this issue to the
summary and discussion chapter. … Peer Reviewer
#1
Summary
and
Discussion
In the discussion section(s) it would be helpful to set
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/home-based-care_disposition-comments.pdf
February 16, 2016 - We have addressed this in the
Discussion. … Peer Reviewer #2 Discussion In the discussion of challenges to synthesizing the literature,
the authors … TEP Reviewer #3 Discussion Yes. … TEP Reviewer #4 Discussion In the discussion the authors should also make a strong
argument and highlight … Commentator &
Affiliation Section Comment Response
Peer Reviewer #3 Discussion The discussion section
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/tonsillectomy-disposition-170415.pdf
January 17, 2017 - Discussion/ Conclusion: Discussion hits on important
issues but is also nuanced. … TEP Reviewer #1 Discussion Discussion/ Conclusion: Implications are clearly
stated. … TEP Reviewer #2 Discussion 2. … TEP reviewer #3 Discussion Discussion/ Conclusion: The discussion sounds like a
repetition of the results … TEP reviewer #4 Discussion e. Discussion/ Conclusion: P 133, lines 21-22 and 28-
30.
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/restless-legs_disposition-comments.pdf
November 27, 2012 - We
have added in our discussion that this study is expected to
be published soon. … Peer Reviewer
#2
Discussion In general, one gets the impression that the Discussion was a
preconceived … We have incorporated new evidence and
peer reviewer comments into our discussion. … Peer Reviewer
#3
Discussion Yes. Thank you. … discussion in RLS.
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/traumatic-brain-injury-rehabilitation_disposition-comments.pdf
October 07, 2012 - At a minimum, I would like to see some
discussion of this issue in the Discussion section. … Peer Reviewer #1 Discussion The Discussion Section appropriately highlights the limitations and challenges … Peer Reviewer #6 Discussion Yes and yes! … Peer Reviewer #11 Discussion Discussion section read well. … Peer Reviewer #14 Discussion The Summary and Discussion Chapter is succinctly focused on the key points
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/hnhc-disposition-comments.pdf
October 29, 2021 - They recommended more discussion of the relationship between the
three analyses and specific recommendations … o Discussion: We added a discussion of the additional complexity of temporality
in relation to patients … In relation to KQ1 studies, we added a
discussion of a reviewer’s point that study regression results … We expanded
our discussion of the connection between our three review approaches to form a
more cohesive … o Discussion: We deleted mention of two organizations that did not meet our
inclusion criteria.
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/linking-evidence-reviews-tools.pdf
October 16, 2018 - to Organizational
Guideline Planning: A Pilot Test of an Interactive, Web-Based Presentation
and Discussion … Conclusions
YMCA Program
Overall Results
YMCA Program Results
CMS Reimbursement
Virtual Sessions
Discussion
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/major-depressive-disorder-disposition-160504.pdf
December 08, 2015 - We address this issue in
the Discussion. … The discussion of herb-drug
interactions is in the introduction and
discussion sections. … #1 Peer Reviewer Discussion
[No page #
provided]
The discussion is also well done. … #2 Peer Reviewer Discussion
[No page #
provided]
In general the discussion is reasonable and thoughtful … Thank you for your comment
#3 Peer Reviewer Discussion
[No page #
provided]
The Discussion is generally
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/cer-237-integrating-palliative-care-disposition-comments.pdf
February 11, 2021 - Lack of sufficient discussion on types of models
4. … Defnition/discussion of the role of “palliative care” in the interventions: We have clarified with
the … We have adjusted
some of the language in the discussion and throughout to address this
point, using … We have added discussion of the three types of models of ambulatory care
addressed in this report. … Public
Reviewer #6
Discussion We also suggest moving discussion in the
findings section about the
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/preterm-birth-terbutaline-pump_disposition-comments.pdf
September 01, 2011 - Some discussion of
this - still tenuous - link should be included in the discussion. … The Discussion ought to emphasize this
point more strongly.
Addressed. … Peer Reviewer 6 Discussion/
Conclusion
The discussion largely reiterates the findings presented in … More discussion of the limits of these data for making conclusions
would be helpful. … We crafted the discussion accordingly.
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/preoperative-testing_disposition-comments.pdf
January 29, 2014 - Peer Reviewer
#4
Discussion Key findings and strength of evidence are clearly described in
the discussion … We have added these concepts to
the Discussion. … Peer Reviewer
#7
Discussion I thought the discussion section for the executive summary was
perhaps … Peer Reviewer
#8
Discussion Adequate discussion of heterogeneity and confounding. … We believe the future research discussion is appropriate.
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/hepatitis-c-treatment-adherence_disposition-comments.pdf
December 20, 2012 - TEP #4 Discussion The discussion is well crafted. … TEP #4 Discussion The discussion describes some important areas for that future
research needs to focus … PR #1 Discussion The results and implications of the major findings are clearly
stated in the Discussion … PR #2 Discussion Main findings are clearly stated. … PR #4 Discussion The overview was nicely done.
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/mental-illness-heart_disposition-comments.pdf
April 22, 2013 - Peer Reviewer 2 Summary/Discussion/Conclusion Discussion is appropriate and consistent with the
review … Peer Reviewer 6 Summary/Discussion/Conclusion 3) A major point missed in the discussion is the issue … Acknowledged
TEP Member 5 Summary/Discussion/Conclusion ok Acknowledged
TEP Member 6 Summary/Discussion … We have added this issue to the
Discussion. … TEP Member 7 Summary/Discussion/Conclusion Another item that may be worth considering in the
discussion
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/cer-262-pharmacotherapy-alcohol-disposition-comments.pdf
November 07, 2023 - Peer Reviewer #3 Discussion/
Conclusion
The discussion section is the highlight of this review. … Again, see my comments in
the Discussion area on this topic. … Technical Expert
#4
Discussion/
Conclusion
Contraindications. … Technical Expert
#4
Discussion/
Conclusion
Future research. … Public Comment
#3 (APA)
Discussion p. 59 Section 4.1.6.
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/stroke-atrial-fibrillation_disposition-comments.pdf
August 23, 2013 - We have also added discussion of the recommended
three-step approach in the overall report Discussion … Should
be in the Discussion. … /
Conclusion
Discussion is generally reasonable. … TEP #1 Summary/
Discussion/
Conclusion
Yes. … TEP #7 Summary/
Discussion/
Conclusion
The major findings are clearly stated, and the
discussion