-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/ijzerman_ahrq-webinar-mcda.pdf
January 01, 2011 - Dia 1
1
Integrating stakeholder preferences in
comparative effectiveness research
using multi-criteria … decision analysis and Conjoint Analysis
Multi-criteria Decision analysis (MCDA) is a subdiscipline … of
operations research that explicitly considers multiple criteria in
decision making. … MCDA will ask you which criteria and levels (Ci and Li) are
important using ranking, rating … Extreme
Decision matrix
11
Eigenvalue to obtain criteria (Ci) and level (Li) weights (1)
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/mhs-IV-patient-family-engagement.pdf
July 01, 2023 - Eligibility Criteria for Studies of Effectiveness
We will search for original studies and systematic … reviews on Review Question 5 according to
the inclusion and exclusion criteria presented in Table … Inclusion and Exclusion Criteria
Study Parameter Inclusion criteria Exclusion criteria
Population … Criteria for Assessing Internal
Validity of Individual Studies. U.S. … Inclusion and Exclusion Criteria
MHS = Making Healthcare Safer; PSP =patient safety practices
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/assessing-quality.ppt
January 01, 2010 - Classify the study design
Apply predefined criteria for quality assessment of each outcome based on: … Apply Predefined Criteria for All Study Types (II)
Apply one of several available tools that consider … Additional Criteria for Trials
Methods used for randomization
Allocation concealment
Blinding of … subjects and providers
Additional Criteria for Trials
Additional Criteria for Observational Studies … Arrive at a Comprehensive Judgment of Quality
After assessment of individual criteria, assign ratings
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/products/autism/research-protocol
December 01, 2019 - criteria developed based on our understanding of the literature developed during the topic refinement … We reviewed these criteria during the first conference call with the TEP, including discussing varied … The TEP felt that criteria related to population, timeframe, setting, and language were appropriate. … Table 1: Inclusion/Exclusion Criteria
Category
Criteria
Study population
Children … Abstract review forms will contain questions about primary exclusion/inclusion criteria.
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/llewellyn-thomas.pdf
January 01, 2011 - Process and
outcome criteria for “good” V/P
elicitation.
• E. Conclusion. … • Or are other process/outcome criteria of greater importance when investigating dynamic
phenomena … Slide
38: SOME PROCESS
COMPARATIVE CRITERIA:
• Operational criteria
• Cognitive psychology criteria … Slide
39: SOME OUTCOME COMPARATIVE CRITERIA:
• Construct validity criteria
• Clinical criteria … • Ethical criteria
• Decision criteria
Slide
40: SO FAR:
• Methodological work about comparative
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/mhs4-failure-rescue-protocol-amendment.pdf
September 19, 2023 - Activation criteria were generated using data gathered from studies that
defined the premonitory signs … Inclusion and Exclusion Criteria
Study
Parameter
Inclusion criteria Exclusion criteria
Population … Inclusion and
Exclusion
Criteria
We will exclude
primary studies that
do not include
hospital … Criteria for Assessing Internal
Validity of Individual Studies. U.S. … Activation criteria were generated using data gath...
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/products/febrile-infants-diagnosis-management/research
December 01, 2019 - The combined clinical and laboratory criteria (Rochester, Philadelphia, Boston, and Milwaukee) demonstrated … but lower specificity compared with criteria based on age, gender, and the degree of fever. … The Rochester criteria were more accurate in neonates than in older infants. … Most of the criteria/protocols demonstrated high negative predictive values and low positive predictive … Combined criteria showed fairly high sensitivity and (therefore) reliability in not missing possible
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/mcda-krishnan.pdf
August 27, 2012 - What about
more topics, and more criteria? … Slide 22
Criteria used by stakeholders
1. Uncertainty about effectiveness
2. … Quantifies relative priorities and can be used to link voting patterns to criteria
2. … Not practical when ‘large’ # topics, criteria
– 9 topics, 7 criteria 252 comparisons
– 5 topics … , 5 criteria 50 comparisons
– 3 topics, 3 criteria 9 comparisons
3.
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/mhs4-implicit-bias-protocol.pdf
August 04, 2023 - Eligibility Criteria for Studies of Effectiveness
We will search for original studies and systematic … reviews on Review Question 5 according to
the inclusion and exclusion criteria presented in Table … Inclusion and Exclusion Criteria
Study Parameter Inclusion criteria Exclusion criteria
Population • … Exclusion criteria
Comparator • No HCW implicit bias training and
education
• Other implicit bias … Criteria for assessing internal validity of individual studies. Rockville (MD): U.S.
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/mhs4-infection-prevention-mdro-protocol.pdf
July 01, 2023 - Inclusion and Exclusion Criteria
Study
Parameter
Inclusion criteria Exclusion criteria
Population … Exclusion criteria
Type of
studies
• Systematic reviews
• Randomized trials
• Non-randomized … In that case, to efficiently identify studies that meet the eligibility criteria, we will distribute … Criteria for Assessing Internal Validity of Individual Studies U.S. … Overview of the PSP
Purpose of the Review
Methodologic Approach
Eligibility Criteria for Studies of
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/products/fibromyalgia/research-protocol
December 01, 2019 - . 9
The diagnostic criteria for fibromyalgia have evolved. 10,11 Fibromyalgia diagnostic criteria … 2011 criteria are labeled preliminary because the current criteria are being vetted for use at the … Study inclusion criteria
Category
Criteria for Study Inclusion
KQ = key question; RCT … the ACR Preliminary Diagnostic Criteria for Fibromyalgia. … Were inclusion/exclusion criteria clearly stated?
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/pdf/masks-prevention-covid-healthcare-community-amended-protocol.pdf
July 02, 2020 - used for research purposes, but should not be considered current.
2
Inclusion and Exclusion Criteria … Quality Assessment
For randomized controlled trials, quality will be assessed using criteria adapted … Section
Original
Protocol
Revised
Protocol Rationale
July 2,
2020
Inclusion/Exclusion
Criteria … /uspstf/appendix-vi-criteria-assessing-
internal-validity-individual-studies. … Living Rapid Review Protocol
Condition or Domain Being Studied
Key Questions
Inclusion and Exclusion Criteria
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/making-healthcare-safer-IV.pdf
August 04, 2023 - Eligibility Criteria for Studies of Effectiveness
We will search for original studies and systematic … reviews on the review questions according to
the inclusion and exclusion criteria presented in Table … Inclusion and Exclusion Criteria
Study Parameter Inclusion criteria Exclusion criteria
Population … To efficiently identify articles that meet the eligibility criteria, we will distribute citations from … Criteria for assessing
internal validity of individual studies [internet]. Rockville (MD): U.S.
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/mhs-IV-surgical-report-cards.pdf
July 01, 2023 - We will identify toolkits without assessing or
endorsing them.
6
Eligibility Criteria for … Inclusion and Exclusion Criteria
Study Parameter Inclusion criteria Exclusion criteria
Population … If we identify a recent eligible systematic review, the reviewer will use the criteria
developed by … Criteria for Assessing Internal Validity of Individual Studies. U.S. … Eligibility Criteria for Studies of Effectiveness
We will search for original studies and systematic
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/products/gout/research-2016
March 01, 2020 - A standardized protocol with predefined criteria was used to extract details on study design, interventions … Using monosodium urate (MSU) crystal analysis as the reference standard, the classification criteria … Thus, imaging findings improved both the sensitivity and specificity of clinical and laboratory criteria … ) or the Clinical Gout Diagnosis criteria was raised from low to moderate. … Study for Updated Gout Classification Criteria (SUGAR): identification of features to classify gout.
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/COVID-19-pharmaceutical-treatments.pdf
December 23, 2023 - Methods
Criteria for Inclusion/Exclusion of Studies in the Review
The eligibility criteria are shown … Eligibility Criteria
Domain
Inclusion criteria Exclusion criteria
Population Pediatric and adult … We will use the pre-established criteria listed in Table 1 to determine eligibility for
inclusion and … Co-morbidities
5
COVID-19 severity level
• Adverse events
Common Terminology Criteria … Common Terminology Criteria for
Adverse Events (CTCAE) Version 5. November 27, 2017.
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/engaging-caregivers-protocol.pdf
August 04, 2023 - Eligibility Criteria for Studies of Effectiveness
We will search for original studies and systematic … reviews on Review Question 5 according to the
inclusion and exclusion criteria presented in Table … Inclusion and exclusion criteria
Study Parameter Inclusion criteria Exclusion criteria
Population Patients … Criteria for assessing
internal validity of individual studies
[internet]. Rockville (MD): U.S. … Eligibility Criteria for Studies of Effectiveness
We will search for original studies and systematic
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/products/binge-eating/research-protocol
December 01, 2019 - Diagnostic Criteria for Binge Eating Disorder and Loss-of-Control Eating
Disorder or behavior … Some consider BED criteria in diagnosing adolescents and others consider LOC eating criteria. … Inclusion/exclusion criteria
Category
Inclusion Criteria
Exclusion Criteria
Abbreviations … Studies that do not include at least one of the outcomes listed in the PICOTS criteria. … We will rate studies that meet all criteria as having “low risk of bias.”
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/febrile-infants-diagnosis-management_executive.pdf
March 01, 2012 - These
studies developed low-risk criteria such as the Philadelphia,
Rochester, and Boston criteria … , (2) clinical
criteria alone, and (3) laboratory criteria alone. … Commonly used combined clinical and laboratory criteria
Boston Criteria Milwaukee Criteria Philadelphia … The PPVs for laboratory criteria alone were
similar to those of the combined criteria, ranging from … criteria alone.
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/medical-test-reviews-risk-bias.ppt
June 01, 2012 - How to apply criteria:
Criteria developed for laboratory studies may not be appropriate for studies of … Principle 2: Standardize the application of study criteria. … Principle 1: Use Validated Criteria To Address Relevant Sources of Bias (1 of 4)
In order to select criteria … Principle 1: Use Validated Criteria To Address Relevant Sources of Bias (2 of 4)
In order to select criteria … Reliability of the ultimate criteria can be measured.