-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/migraine-emergency_disposition-comments.pdf
November 27, 2012 - Similarly, consider adding “adult” somewhere in the Conclusion. … Peer Reviewer
#2
Discussion/conclusion Discussion/ Conclusion: On page 121, they list promethazine … Peer Reviewer
#3
Discussion/conclusion The conclusions are well sounded and appropriate. … Peer Reviewer
#8
Discussion/conclusion In the Conclusion section (P 110), why is DHE combined with … Peer Reviewer
#13
Discussion/conclusion excellent Thank you for your comment.
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/cer-232-breathlessness-cancer-comments.pdf
November 19, 2020 - At the conclusion of the public comment period, authors use the
commentators’ comments to revise the … My
conclusion based on the evidence is that there the
evidence is inconclusive rather than opioids … We have carefully reviewed this conclusion
with this comment in mind and felt it was appropriate. … There is inadequate
data to
reach a conclusion regarding efficacy and further
research is needed. … Reviewer #5 Discussion/
Conclusion
I do have several suggestions for this section.
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/cer-200-comments-post-acs.pdf
November 14, 2017 - TEP #2 Discussion/
Conclusion
The major findings were clearly stated. … TEP #5 Discussion/
Conclusion
p. 37. lines 42-43. … TEP #5 Discussion/
Conclusion
p. 38. Research Recommendations. … TEP #6 Discussion/
Conclusion
3) No omissions to my knowledge. Thank you.
94. … Peer Reviewer #4 Discussion/
Conclusion
This is very detailed and clear.
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/cer-224-depression-children-comments.pdf
April 10, 2020 - Peer reviewer #1
Discussion/
Conclusion
Key messages are explicit and applicable. … This part of the Discussion section basically includes the
summary and/or conclusion as well. … We added a header “conclusion” above the
closing paragraph. … TEP member #3
Discussion/
Conclusion
Yes Thank you. … Peer reviewer #4 Discussion/
Conclusion
Note: Reviewer referred to above results comments.
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/alcohol-misuse-drug-therapy-surveillance.pdf
September 01, 2017 - Is this conclusion still supported by the evidence?
b. … Is there other new evidence that may change this conclusion? … Each row refers to a separate conclusion/finding from the full report. … Each row refers to a separate
conclusion/finding from the full report. … Column 3 contains expert response to “is this conclusion still supported?”
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/antipsychotics-children-surveillance-150120.pdf
October 01, 2014 - • For Key Question 3, the conclusion on the safety and tolerability of FGAs
vs. … experts assessed the CER conclusion as having new evidence that might change the
conclusion, then we … classified the CER conclusion as possibly out of date … we classified the CER conclusion as out of date. … • Key Question 3: Conclusion on the safety and tolerability of FGAs vs.
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/undescended-testicle_disposition-comments.pdf
December 11, 2012 - At the conclusion
of the public comment period, authors use the commentators’ submissions and comments … Peer Reviewer #6 Discussion-
Conclusion
4. … Peer Reviewer #6 Discussion-
Conclusion
6. … Peer Reviewer #7 Discussion-
Conclusion
Future research covered in Research Gaps section. … Peer Reviewer #7 Discussion-
Conclusion
Disagree with the conclusion on long-term outcomes- some data
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/colorectal-cancer-staging_disposition-comments.pdf
November 20, 2014 - See additional comments in the
discussions/conclusion section as per below. … Discussion/ Conclusion: Are the implications of the major
findings clearly stated? Yes. … Peer Reviewer 5 Discussion/Conclusion e. … Peer Reviewer 3 Conclusion The second issue in the manuscript is the conclusion that CT is as
good as … Discussion/ Conclusion: Conclusion statements
I am concerned that the conclusion statements can be
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/cer-217-management-of-infertility-comments.pdf
May 14, 2019 - At the conclusion of the public
comment period, authors use the commentators’ submissions and comments … In
isolation the conclusion can be be misleading. … Peer Reviewer #4 Results The conclusion for endometriosis is misleading. … Peer Reviewer #1 Discussion/
Conclusion
Sufficient Thank you. No response needed.
134. … TEP Reviewer #3 Discussion/
Conclusion
Page 30, line 22.
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/colorectal-cancer-liver-metastases-therapies_disposition-comments.pdf
December 11, 2012 - At the conclusion
of the public comment period, authors use the commentators’ submissions and comments … The final conclusion that a conclusion
cannot be made is not surprising but I think is in important … Thank you
Peer Reviewer #5
Discussion/
Conclusion
Overall I agree with the general conclusion … Peer Reviewer #5
Discussion/
Conclusion
2. They are difficult to accrue. … Peer Reviewer #5
Discussion/
Conclusion
The proposal for an IO registry is misguided.
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/chronic-urinary-retention_disposition-comments.pdf
September 15, 2014 - At the conclusion of the public comment period, authors
use the commentators’ submissions and comments … Conclusion Conclusions are valid. … Conclusion
Figures The figures, tables, and appendices are adequate and
descriptive. … I do not think
the study design allows that conclusion. … The future research section is spot on and really is the main
conclusion of the manuscript.
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/antipsychotics-adults_surveillance.pdf
August 30, 2014 - and this portion of the CER may not be current
• Original conclusion is out of date. … as still valid, we classified the CER conclusion as likely not out of date … experts assessed the CER conclusion as having new evidence that might change the
conclusion, then we … classified the CER conclusion as possibly out of date … we classified the CER conclusion as out of date.
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/colorectal-surgery-preparation_disposition-comments.pdf
April 30, 2014 - We respectfully disagree with this conclusion. … We have reached the
same conclusion as the reviewer. … TEP #6 Conclusion I disagree with your conclusions. … TEP #6 Conclusion As above, I think the conclusions are too conservative-I think the
conclusion should … TEP #7
Conclusion The conclusion is reasonable and based on the evidence provided. Thank you.
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/depression-postpartum-screening_disposition-comments.pdf
May 01, 2013 - Your conclusion is overreaching. … Peer Reviewer 2 Summary/Discussion/Conclusion Discussion [p. 60 Figure 10]. … TEP Member 6 Summary/Discussion/Conclusion The implications are clear. … TEP Member 8 Summary/Discussion/Conclusion The discussion/conclusion is clear and thorough,
with useful … Elizabeth
Summary/Discussion/Conclusion I am sorry I had to stop here.
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/cancer-pancreas_disposition-comments.pdf
September 23, 2014 - Thus it seems that our conclusion is worded
appropriately. … We did not draw a conclusion for lymph node
staging accuracy due to insufficient evidence. … Discussion/ Conclusion: yes No response necessary
TEP Reviewer 2 Discussion e. … Discussion/ Conclusion: Generally yes. No response necessary
TEP Reviewer 3 Discussion e. … We stand by our conclusion as well as its evidence
grade (moderate).
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/mrsa-screening-2010_disposition-comments.pdf
January 01, 2010 - Reviewer #2
(TEP)
Discussion/
Conclusion
Discussion/ Conclusion: Very well written, summarizes … Reviewer #3
(Peer)
Discussion/
Conclusion
Discussion/ Conclusion: It may be beneficial to have … Reviewer #4
(Peer)
Discussion/
Conclusion
Discussion/ Conclusion: Excellent. … Reviewer #6
(Peer)
Discussion/
Conclusion
Discussion/ Conclusion Executive Summary: 15. … Reviewer #8
(Peer)
Discussion/
Conclusion
Discussion/ Conclusion: Page 64.
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/hemorrhage-postpartum_disposition-comments.pdf
April 28, 2015 - At the conclusion of the public comment
period, authors use the commentators’ submissions and comments … TEP Reviewer #1 Discussion/
Conclusion
Syntax error line 21 p 107 or in place of “of” Corrected … TEP Reviewer #1 Discussion/
Conclusion
The last recommendation is quite provocative regarding
the … TEP Reviewer #1 Discussion/
Conclusion
Methods for dealing with confounding by indication
should … TEP Reviewer #2 Discussion/
Conclusion
See comment numbers 3, 12 and 14 above.
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/pressure-ulcer-treatment_disposition-comments.pdf
May 08, 2013 - Reviewer: 5 Discussion/Conclusion Clear statements of existing limits
of literature. … Reviewer: 8 Discussion/Conclusion I had no concerns about the major
findings. … Reviewer: 8 Discussion/Conclusion I had no concerns about the major
findings. … Catherine
Ratliff
Discussion/Conclusion Good Thank you for your comment. … Laura Bolton Discussion/Conclusion I would question the validity of
reaching any conclusion about
'
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/autism-adolescents_surveillance.pdf
July 01, 2014 - as still valid, we classified the CER conclusion as likely not out of date … experts assessed the CER conclusion as having new evidence that might change the
conclusion, then we … classified the CER conclusion as possibly out of date … we classified the CER conclusion as out of date. … Has there been new evidence that
may change this conclusion?
-
effectivehealthcare-admin.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/diabetic-neuropathy-disposition-170707.pdf
March 24, 2017 - At the conclusion of the public
comment period, authors use the commentators’ submissions and comments … Peer reviewer #1 Discussion/
Conclusion
please see under general comments
TEP #3 Discussion/
Conclusion … Peer reviewer #2 Discussion/
Conclusion
1. … Peer reviewer #2 Discussion/
Conclusion
2. … Peer reviewer #2 Discussion/
Conclusion
3.