-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/allergy-seasonal_disposition-comments.pdf
July 17, 2013 - The Authors listed those conditions as inclusion
criteria. … It
might be beneficial if the Authors could clarify that in the
manuscript. … It might be beneficial if the Authors reworded this sentence. … Report authors and AHRQ agreed upon table format after
discussion. … The
authors should be commended for their work on this review.
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/renal-function_disposition-comments.pdf
August 11, 2014 - At the conclusion of the public comment period, authors
use the commentators’ submissions and comments … Comments on draft reviews and the authors’ responses to the comments are posted for
public viewing on … The tables below include the responses by the authors of the review to each comment that
was submitted … Peer reviewer #2 Discussion The authors describe well the implications of the major findings. … As equally important, the
authors provide guidance for future research on the topic.
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/ptsd-dispositIon-comments-2022.pdf
January 01, 2022 - Comments on draft reports and the authors’ responses to the comments are posted
for public viewing … Perhaps the authors want to suggest new standards for the
field? … Pg 42, line 15: are there any other trends that the authors
noticed among the new studies. … and I
appreciated the transparency and detail with which the
authors discussed them. … The report authors are not involved in tracking
reports on the AHRQ website.
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/vte-prophyalaxis_disposition-comments.pdf
May 29, 2013 - Reviewer 9 Methods Authors have considered appropriate outcome measures. … The authors display study data in tables and figures in an easily
understandable way. … The
authors are still working on the paper. … Therefore, as a reader, I would like to have the authors
design a theoretical study. … In this regard the authors provide
some guidance to the research community.
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/hospital-length-of-stay-disposition-comments.pdf
September 20, 2021 - At the conclusion of the public comment period, authors use
the commentators’ comments to revise the … Comments on draft reports and the authors’ responses to the comments are posted
for public viewing … The responses to comments in this disposition report are
those of the authors, who are responsible … Can the authors reconcile this? … I appreciate that the authors noted this and commented
forcefully about this.
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/hospital-length-of-stay-disposition-comments_0.pdf
September 20, 2021 - At the conclusion of the public comment period, authors use
the commentators’ comments to revise the … Comments on draft reports and the authors’ responses to the comments are posted
for public viewing … The responses to comments in this disposition report are
those of the authors, who are responsible … Can the authors reconcile this? … I appreciate that the authors noted this and commented
forcefully about this.
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/ems-911-workforce-disposition-comments.pdf
November 01, 2022 - At the conclusion of the public comment period, authors use the
commentators’ comments to revise the … Comments on draft reports and the authors’ responses to the comments are posted
for public viewing … This document includes the responses by the authors of the report to comments that were
submitted for … The responses to comments in this disposition report are those of
the authors, who are responsible … Alexander Isakov Executive
Summary
When the authors state that “Research into EMS/911 infectious
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/postpartum-care-one-year-disposition-comments.pdf
June 02, 2023 - At
the conclusion of the public comment period, authors use the commentators’ comments to revise … The EPC authors clarified these aspects. … The EPC authors made
these corrections. … The EPC authors incorporated these
requested details in the report. … The EPC authors added those details
to the Discussion.
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/pdf/methods-guidance-reporting-bias_methods.pdf
November 01, 2013 - contacting authors in the context of conducting
a systematic review. … • When reviewers contact authors, they should report the number of authors they attempted
to contact … , the number of authors actually contacted, and the percentage of authors who
responded positively to … IOM Standard 3.2.3 states that, in addition to contacting study authors and researchers,
authors of … • If authors of primary studies are contacted, the review should report the authors contacted
and
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/osteoporosis-vibration-therapy_disposition-comments.pdf
November 15, 2011 - The authors did publish their criteria for selecting literature. … Peer Reviewer #2 Findings l. 8 Do the authors mean 50-100 Hz? 5 doesn't seem very high to me. … Peer Reviewer #2 Findings l. 8-10 The authors make a very strong statement here. … It
appears that the authors have included all relevant studies. … A-1 The authors need to revise the criteria for the bone density
classifications.
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/peripheral-artery-disease-treatment_disposition-comments.pdf
May 29, 2013 - Comments on draft reviews and the authors’ responses to the comments are posted for
public viewing on … The authors should explain
the impact changes of usual care on the treatment of
PAD. … The authors
must clarify this for these guidelines to be of value. … The authors are
also dismissive of results of studies that suggest a
benefit of surgery. … The authors continue to be
dismissive of surgery.
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/kidney-stone-prevention_disposition-comments.pdf
July 26, 2012 - The authors
only included randomized controlled trials. … The search strategy the authors
employ is exhaustive and thorough. … The authors
only included randomized controlled trials. … The search strategy the authors
employ is exhaustive and thorough. … The key questions presented by the authors are appropriate to
the topic.
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/cer-245-breast-reconstruction-after-mastectomy-disposition-comments.pdf
October 01, 2021 - Comments on draft reports and the authors’ responses to the comments are posted for
public viewing on … This document includes the responses by the authors of the report to comments that
were submitted for … Reviewers noted that the authors are “appropriately cautious regarding the findings.” … The EPC authors made these
corrections. … The EPC
authors added those details to the Discussion.
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/cer-200-comments-post-acs.pdf
November 14, 2017 - Comments on draft reviews and the authors’ responses to the comments are posted for
public viewing on … The authors didn't address these aspects in their
manuscript. … If yes, how did the
authors decide which exclusion was the "reason". … I would prefer the authors be
more specific. … The authors should seek to resolve this
potential mixed message.
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/arthritis-knee-physical-therapy_disposition-comments.pdf
November 06, 2012 - However the authors did not make clear what "physical
therapy" interventions are. … Unfortunately, the authors did not discuss how they
made the OA diagnosis. … Peer Reviewer # 6 Results The authors need more detailed legends. … The authors findings are in conflict with existing
clinical guidelines. but the authors fail to discuss … The authors appear to have defined physical therapy
as various modalities.
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/reporting-quiz.ppt
January 01, 2009 - Reporting guidelines advocate the use of a checklist, a flow diagram, or explicit text to guide authors … literature search — including the databases used, dates covered in each database, and any contacts with authors … If authors do not provide sufficient details concerning the conduct of their CER, readers are left with … If the authors indicate in the Methods section that they assessed the quality (risk of bias) of the included … The PRISMA Statement is a reporting guideline that authors can follow when preparing a report on a systematic
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/disposition-of-comments-cer-192-anxiety-in-children.pdf
August 31, 2017 - Of the 8
studies cited by the authors in “Table
10. … was missing
information, we contacted the authors”
(p. 16). … Were authors contacted for
information that would enable subgroup
analyses? … We contacted authors for missing
data. But few responded. … The
authors note this in their Limitations
section.
Thank you.
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/prostate-cancer-risk-assessment-genes_disposition-comments.pdf
July 03, 2012 - At the conclusion
of the public comment period, authors use the commentators’ submissions and comments … Comments on draft reviews and the authors’ responses to the comments are posted for
public viewing on … The tables below include the responses by the authors of the review to each comment
that was submitted … The responses to comments in this disposition report
are those of the authors, who are responsible for … The authors prefer
to leave the text as currently written as we feel it
is explicit.
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/hypertensive-disorders-pregnancy-disposition-comments.pdf
May 31, 2023 - At the conclusion of the public
comment period, authors use the commentators’ comments to revise the … Comments on draft reports and the authors’ responses to the comments are posted
for public viewing … The responses to comments in this disposition report are those of
the authors, who are responsible … EPC authors believe these issues are very important for the authors of
clinical practice guidelines … On review, EPC authors
found this study was included. Other studies were suggested for inclusion.
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/traumatic-brain-injury-rehabilitation_disposition-comments.pdf
October 07, 2012 - At the conclusion of the public
comment period, authors use the commentators’ submissions and comments … Comments on draft reviews and the authors’ responses to the comments are posted for
public viewing on … The authors followed customary guidelines for a review of this type. … But I think
the authors do as good a job as they can with limited conclusions. … The authors
described the targeted population thoroughly and succinctly.