-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/cer-200-comments-post-acs.pdf
November 14, 2017 - We’ve modified our
description, commented on the
uncertainty of this estimate, and
provided citations … not changed over that
period and evidence from before 2005 is just as valid as
evidence after that year … We have added the
inclusion of power to our methods
description.
63. … We do not
think a detailed description (i.e.,
specific codes) adds to the
discussion.
89. … We reviewed and edited our
description of intervention impact
on cardiac outcomes.
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/chronic-pain-opioid-treatment_disposition-comments.pdf
September 29, 2014 - Given this description, there seems to be a broad degree of
“quality” within this single category. … for Clinical and Policy Decisionmaking section, the first paragraph
seems to represent an accurate description … We
edited the typo where it should have
said >1 year. … In Summary Tables A and 6, the conclusion column sometimes includes a brief
description of the source … Peer Reviewer 7 Results Page ES-23, lines 18-23-here and in subsequent sections, the description of the
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/gout-management-disposition-160721.pdf
March 15, 2016 - We added to the SoE
description the factors we used in judging
the SoE as moderate. … But we can't follow the
reviewer's description of the clinical effects
of this. … So 4 attacks per year reduced to 2.4
attacks per year, and unfortunately no
statistical testing was … We have moved the description of studies
that assess nutritional risk factors for gout
or high serum … TEP Reviewer #3 Introduction Background: • ES-1, line 55: the description of joints involved should
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/public-reporting-cost-measures_disposition-comments.pdf
March 05, 2015 - The guiding questions cover the
following: a description of the measures of cost that have been publicly … Based on that description, the Maine
website also sounded to me like the website was giving data on … Recommend more nuanced description of next steps needed to further
validate, rather than only how the … I did not see any description of other grading
systems? … Reviewer#4 General
Comments
This is a very nicely executed scan and description of public reporting
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/asd-interventions-disposition.pdf
May 26, 2017 - The excluded studies appendix is organized by
year and then alphabetically. … major topic areas were
presented with conclusions and then further in the document, there's
more description … TEP
Reviewer #1
Methods Sensory report: good description of categorization of interventions. … Description of included
studies well done; table 2 provides a good overview of types of studies
included … Discussion/Con
clusion
Finally, ref. 42 is not correct – it is to an RCT protocol by the same
author
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/people-with-disabilities-protocol.pdf
January 16, 2024 - The earliest search date will be limited to the
year 1990, the year of the passage of the Americans … Contacting Author. … inclusion criteria, data will be abstracted into Excel tables, including
elements such as: study design, year … Questions 2, 3, and 4), we will consider using a framework such as the Template for Intervention
Description … Better reporting of interventions: template
for intervention description and replication
(TIDieR) checklist
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/rotator-cuff-tear_disposition-comments.pdf
October 05, 2010 - We have add a brief description of
the scale in the paragraph outlining the Leroux study (page 132): … et al
(2001) paper was excluded since this publication did not report
baseline data (only 2 and 10 year … by considering the Galatz paper a multiple
publication of the earlier study, and have added the 10-year … We have rephrased the description of outcome
measures using the terms “patient self-reported” and “clinician … Bassett RW et al, 1983; this study was excluded because
it was published before the year 1990.
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/peripheral-artery-disease-treatment_disposition-comments.pdf
May 29, 2013 - Definitions of the type of
supervised exercise therapy vary across studies, but
we have added a general description … however, suggest that
“..amputation-free survival favored endovascular
interventions with low SOE at 1 year … considerably
better primary patency compared to endovascular
treatments for CLI at intermediate (1 year … In the studies we reviewed, the RCTs
and prospective observational studies had a
description of how
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/mhs-IV-rapid-response-surgical-report-cards.pdf
November 01, 2023 - Low
Making Healthcare Safer IV – Use of Report Cards and Outcome Measurements
39
Author, Year … High
Making Healthcare Safer IV – Use of Report Cards and Outcome Measurements
40
Author, Year … High
Making Healthcare Safer IV – Use of Report Cards and Outcome Measurements
42
Author, Year … High
Making Healthcare Safer IV – Use of Report Cards and Outcome Measurements
44
Author, Year … Summary of studies describing collaboratives
Author, Year
Study Design
PSP/Name of
Collaborative
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/antipsychotics-children-update-disposition-170621.pdf
March 16, 2017 - The outcomes and
description of harm types were also clear and
sensible. … The most notable shortcoming was the
lack of a detailed description of the meta-analytic
models. … We have added this as well as more description
of the methods (in Appendix G). … sub-group effects, or were
removed for the various sensitivity analyses; we
have added the study author … TEP 5 Discussion Good description of the limitations of the CER. What
and why were explained.
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/antipsychotics-children-update-disposition-170621.pdf
March 16, 2017 - The outcomes and
description of harm types were also clear and
sensible. … The most notable shortcoming was the
lack of a detailed description of the meta-analytic
models. … We have added this as well as more description
of the methods (in Appendix G). … sub-group effects, or were
removed for the various sensitivity analyses; we
have added the study author … TEP 5 Discussion Good description of the limitations of the CER. What
and why were explained.
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/obesity-child_disposition-comments.pdf
June 10, 2013 - On printed p. 1 a description of the
different settings is presented. … We have included a less detailed description.
76 Peer Reviewer 3 Executive
Summary
Page 12, Table … This study was excluded for lack of sufficient followup description
129 TEP 3 Methods Page 6, line … We agree – this was very rarely reported.
134 Peer Reviewer 3 Results Page 40, Description of type … headings: physical/environmental, and educational (which has been
changed to psychosocial) are a description
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/adhd_disposition-comments.pdf
October 01, 2011 - 10 year earlier
steeper change. … Rewritten, Adderall is approved for ≥3 year olds
in USA, and ≥6 year olds in Canada p 27 of 278
Peer … Description of GRADE approach on page 25
would be useful. … Results Table 6, page 66 of 255, Ghuman 2007 study: Author’s first name initial
is incorrect; the author … Results (5) Table 6, page 66 of 255, Ghuman 2007 study: Author’s first name
initial is incorrect; the author
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/weight-loss-surgery_disposition-comments.pdf
June 05, 2013 - More appropriate would be a more concise description of
biliopancreatic diversion with duodenal switch … 2013
6
Commentator &
Affiliation Section Comment Response
TEP 4 Introduction Regarding description … Studies that measured out to one year or more reported
continued improvement in HbA1c values. … Unfortunately the data
collection (as noted by the author) is weak and very little is
published about … not limited to paragraphs on page 16,
19,22, 26, 38,42, 46,47,48,49, 64, 70,
We have revised the description
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/cancer-survivor-care-transition_disposition-comments.pdf
March 18, 2014 - This section may benefit from a brief
description of the landscape of late effects. … The year of the
study, the timing relative to cancer diagnosis and
treatment, the frequency and duration … survivorship
intervention and duration of intervention could be
described rather than categorized as <1 year … or
≥1 year. … Some typos: should be first author and year,
check alignment of X’s.
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/lifecycle-assessment-disposition-comments.pdf
November 20, 2024 - lifecycle-assessment/tech-brief
Published Online: November 20, 2024
2
Peer Reviewer and Public Comments and Author … There doesn’t appear to be any description of the
decades of LCA work on waste management. … Just because an author (of an original study) calls
something an LCA framework doesn’t make it
one. … This section is much too short and just
appears to be a description of several studies with
no description … With Products, Processes, and Waste
Comments to Draft Report
Peer Reviewer and Public Comments and Author
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/maternal-child-outcomes-wic-disposition-comments.pdf
April 19, 2022 - outcomes-nutrition/research
Published Online: April 19, 2022
2
Summary of Peer Reviewer Comments and Author … products/outcomes-nutrition/research
Published Online: April 19, 2022
3
Public Comments and Author … Association
(NWA)
Introduction The introduction section similarly is accurate and detailed in its description … Thank you
National WIC
Association
(NWA)
Methods Include a brief description on the funding sources … We have edited as suggested
National WIC
Association
(NWA)
Discussion WIC’s funding description
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/pdf/undescended-testicle_research-protocol.pdf
September 02, 2011 - We set a cut-off year of 1980 for all included publications. … evidence table may vary by KQ as appropriate, but the
tables will contain some common elements, such as author … , year of publication, study location
(e.g., country, city, state) and time period, population description … the ability to
apply the intervention to other populations or other settings, such as inadequate description … J Urol 2008;180:783-4; author reply 784-5.
PMID: 18555491.
13. Wood HM, Elder JS.
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/quality-gap-palliative-hospice_disposition-comments.pdf
October 01, 2012 - We have also added this
as a further description of the
heterogeneity in the pain section:
“Moreover … There is no reference provided for this specific
year. … year as 2010). … More description of the studies - including why it is
counted as QI study. … We have clarified in a footnote that the
different author studies are actually
different publications
-
effectivehealthcare.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/related_files/tech-brief-31-mobile-applications-self-mgmt.pdf
May 01, 2018 - Study details for apps for type 1 diabetes
App Name
Author & Year
Length of
Study
ROB
Assessment … Study details for apps for type 2 diabetes
App Name
Author & Year
Length of
Study
ROB
Assessment … NA
C-10
App Name
Author & Year
Length of
Study
ROB
Assessment
Participants Intervention … NA
C-12
App Name
Author & Year
Length of
Study
ROB
Assessment
Participants Intervention … NA
C-14
App Name
Author & Year
Length of
Study
ROB
Assessment
Participants Intervention